Computer lipreading via hybrid deep neural network hidden Markov models

Constructing a viable lipreading system is a challenge because it is claimed that only 30% of information of speech production is visible on the lips. Nevertheless, in small vocabulary tasks, there have been several reports of high accuracies. However, investigation of larger vocabulary tasks is rare. This work examines constructing a large vocabulary lipreading system using an approach based-on Deep Neural Network Hidden Markov Models (DNN-HMMs). We present the historical development of computer lipreading technology and the state-ofthe-art results in small and large vocabulary tasks. In preliminary experiments, we evaluate the performance of lipreading and audiovisual speech recognition in small vocabulary data sets. We then concentrate on the improvement of lipreading systems in a more substantial vocabulary size with a multi-speaker data set. We tackle the problem of lipreading an unseen speaker. We investigate the effect of employing several stepstopre-processvisualfeatures. Moreover, weexaminethecontributionoflanguage modelling in a lipreading system where we use longer n-grams to recognise visual speech. Our lipreading system is constructed on the 6000-word vocabulary TCDTIMIT audiovisual speech corpus. The results show that visual-only speech recognition can definitely reach about 60% word accuracy on large vocabularies. We actually achieved a mean of 59.42% measured via three-fold cross-validation on the speaker independent setting of the TCD-TIMIT corpus using Deep autoencoder features and DNN-HMM models. This is the best word accuracy of a lipreading system in a large vocabulary task reported on the TCD-TIMIT corpus. In the final part of the thesis, we examine how the DNN-HMM model improves lipreading performance. We also give an insight into lipreading by providing a feature visualisation. Finally, we present an analysis of lipreading results and suggestions for future development

Improving computer lipreading via DNN sequence discriminative training techniques

Although there have been some promising results in computer lipreading, there has been a paucity of data on which to train automatic systems. However the recent emergence of the TCD-TIMIT corpus, with around 6000 words, 59 speakers and seven hours of recorded audio-visual speech, allows the deployment of more recent techniques in audio-speech such as Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) and sequence discriminative training. In this paper we combine the DNN with a Hidden Markov Model (HMM) to the, so called, hybrid DNN-HMM configuration which we train using a variety of sequence discriminative training methods. This is then followed with a weighted finite state transducer. The conclusion is that the DNN offers very substantial improvement over a conventional classifier which uses a Gaussian Mixture Model (GMM) to model the densities even when optimised with Speaker Adaptive Training. Sequence adaptive training offers further improvements depending on the precise variety employed but those improvements are of the order of ~10\% improvement in word accuracy. Putting these two results together implies that lipreading is moving from something of rather esoteric interest to becoming a practical reality in the foreseeable future

Comparing phonemes and visemes with DNN-based lipreading

There is debate if phoneme or viseme units are the most effective for a lipreading system. Some studies use phoneme units even though phonemes describe unique short sounds; other studies tried to improve lipreading accuracy by focusing on visemes with varying results. We compare the performance of a lipreading system by modeling visual speech using either 13 viseme or 38 phoneme units. We report the accuracy of our system at both word and unit levels. The evaluation task is large vocabulary continuous speech using the TCD-TIMIT corpus. We complete our visual speech modeling via hybrid DNN-HMMs and our visual speech decoder is aWeighted Finite-State Transducer (WFST). We use DCT and Eigenlips as a representation of mouth ROI image. The phoneme lipreading system word accuracy outperforms the viseme based system word accuracy. However, the phoneme system achieved lower accuracy at the unit level which shows the importance of the dictionary for decoding classification outputs into words

Improving Lip-reading Performance for Robust Audiovisual Speech Recognition using DNNs

This paper presents preliminary experiments using the Kaldi toolkit to investigate audiovisual speech recognition (AVSR) in noisy environments using deep neural networks (DNNs). In particular we use a single-speaker large vocabulary, continuous audiovisual speech corpus to compare the performance of visual-only, audio-only and audiovisual speech recognition. The models trained using the Kaldi toolkit are compared with the performance of models trained using conventional hidden Markov models (HMMs). In addition, we compare the performance of a speech recognizer both with and without visual features over nine different SNR levels of babble noise ranging from 20dB down to -20dB. The results show that the DNN outperforms conventional HMMs in all experimental conditions, especially for the lip-reading only system, which achieves a gain of 37.19% accuracy (84.67% absolute word accuracy). Moreover, the DNN provides an effective improvement of 10 and 12dB SNR respectively for both the single modal and bimodal speech recognition systems. However, integrating the visual features using simple feature fusion is only effective in SNRs at 5dB and above. Below this the degradion in accuracy of an audiovisual system is similar to the audio only recognizer. Index Terms: lip-reading, speech reading, audiovisual speech recognitio